Standard Operating Procedure for Reproducibility Assessment Across Analytical Runs in BA/BE Studies
| Department | BA-BE Studies |
|---|---|
| SOP No. | SOP/BA-BE/187/2025 |
| Supersedes | SOP/BA-BE/187/2022 |
| Page No. | Page 1 of 9 |
| Issue Date | 17/04/2025 |
| Effective Date | 20/04/2025 |
| Review Date | 17/04/2026 |
1. Purpose
To establish a standardized procedure for assessing reproducibility between multiple analytical runs conducted during bioanalytical phases of BA/BE studies, ensuring data reliability, consistency, and acceptance by regulatory authorities.
2. Scope
This SOP applies to all analytical runs performed using validated methods in bioanalytical laboratories involved in BA/BE studies, where reproducibility across runs is required to verify method consistency.
3. Responsibilities
- Analytical Scientist: Prepares
and analyzes reproducibility samples across different runs.
QC Reviewer: Reviews %CV calculations and verifies inter-run consistency.
QA Officer: Ensures reproducibility assessments are performed and documented for all applicable studies.
4. Accountability
The Bioanalytical Department Head is accountable for ensuring reproducibility assessments are planned, executed, and reviewed in compliance with regulatory requirements.
5. Procedure
5.1 Planning Reproducibility Assessment
- Identify need for reproducibility assessment:
- Multiple analytical runs within the same study
- Samples analyzed on different days or instruments
- Regulatory requirements such as for ISR (incurred sample reanalysis)
- Select quality control (QC) samples or real subject samples previously analyzed in a qualifying run.
- Prepare a Reproducibility Plan in Annexure-1: Reproducibility Assessment Plan.
5.2 Sample Selection and Reanalysis
- Select at least 10% of total samples (preferably ISR samples) or a minimum of 20 samples, as per ICH M10 guidance.
- Ensure selected samples:
- Cover high, medium, and low concentration ranges
- Have sufficient volume for repeat analysis
- Reanalyze selected samples using the same validated method in a different run on a different day.
5.3 Data Calculation and Acceptance Criteria
- Calculate % difference using:
%Difference = ((Reanalysis - Original) / Mean) × 100 - Acceptability criteria:
- At least 67% of samples must show ≤20% difference from original result
- Document all calculations in Annexure-2: Reproducibility Assessment Log.
5.4 Evaluation and Documentation
- Summarize reproducibility results in the method validation or study report.
- Attach reproducibility chromatograms, audit trails, and raw data for both runs.
- Ensure all findings are signed and dated by the Analyst and Reviewed by QA.
5.5 Non-Conformance and Investigation
- If < 67% of reanalyzed samples exceed 20% difference:
- Initiate deviation report
- Conduct root cause analysis (RCA)
- Document CAPA using Annexure-3: Deviation and CAPA Form
- Repeat assessment with new sample set, if justified.
6. Abbreviations
- BA/BE: Bioavailability/Bioequivalence
- ISR: Incurred Sample Reanalysis
- RCA: Root Cause Analysis
- CAPA: Corrective and Preventive Action
- QC: Quality Control
- %CV: Percent Coefficient of Variation
7. Documents
- Reproducibility Assessment Plan – Annexure-1
- Reproducibility Assessment Log – Annexure-2
- Deviation and CAPA Form – Annexure-3
8. References
- ICH M10: Bioanalytical Method Validation
- FDA Guidance for Industry – Bioanalytical Method Validation (2022)
- WHO TRS No. 992 – Good practices for pharmaceutical quality control laboratories
9. SOP Version
Version: 2.0
10. Approval Section
| Prepared By | Checked By | Approved By | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Signature | |||
| Date | |||
| Name | |||
| Designation | |||
| Department |
11. Annexures
Annexure-1: Reproducibility Assessment Plan
| Study ID | Method Name | Analyst | Samples Selected | Run Date (Original/Repeat) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BAE-097 | LC-MS/MS Method 3 | Rajesh Kumar | PL-111 to PL-130 | 15/04/2025 / 17/04/2025 |
Annexure-2: Reproducibility Assessment Log
| Sample ID | Original Result (ng/mL) | Reanalysis (ng/mL) | % Difference | Pass/Fail |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PL-112 | 45.2 | 46.1 | 2.0% | Pass |
Annexure-3: Deviation and CAPA Form
| Deviation ID | Description | Root Cause | CAPA | Closure Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| DEV-2025-04 | Failed reproducibility in ISR batch | Improper sample thawing | Re-training conducted | 18/04/2025 |
Revision History:
| Revision Date | Revision No. | Details | Reason | Approved By |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01/01/2022 | 1.0 | Initial SOP Release | New SOP | QA Head |
| 17/04/2025 | 2.0 | Added CAPA linkage and expanded annexures | Regulatory Alignment | QA Head |